Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-2240864-20140924222143/@comment-25329286-20141001154000

Xelrog T. Apocalypse wrote: "Notch's prank?" If you're talking about the whole "Removed Herobrine" note that gets added to all the Minecraft patch updates, that didn't happen until long after the rumors were going.

A page exists here, though, and if the comments are to be believed then it's the "original" creepypasta. It's already in Classics, fittingly enough. Okay, that was my only suggestion. You've got a pretty good list already. Maybe The Devil Game? It's pretty popular. I don't know.