User blog comment:Banningk1979/Jeff the Killer Re-Write Idea/@comment-25073641-20150919170327

"Why bother trying to bring the dead back to life when you can create another life?"

As for that, I think this has a huge point. Anyone wouldn't find it bad if Jeff the Killer was entirely rewritten but the story was kept (but how can anyone eliminate those clichés?). There are so many good writers out there who can breathe a new life to this fallen creepypasta, and I'm making point here, right?

But the real problem is how writers can rewrite the pasta without adjusting or removing much of the details. It would be a damned huge catastrophe if writers try to make an unrealistic pasta "realistic", like... what can I substitute to carving a smile on their face without bleeding much and dying of pain. That would be terribly hard. Can anyone burn eyelids? Unless you had outrageously low pain threshold, then yes, if not, no.

And concealing (at least, if not removing) those clichés would be an almost impossible thing to do. We all know (correct me if I'm wrong; thank you) that JtK revolves around clichés and things like these. So if anyone tries to hide those flaws, it would be almost changing the story and plot altogether. And that sounds a bit of vandalism.

The point is: it's almost impposibru and bone-breakingly hard, but it also has a very big potential. I may have a neutral opinion on this one.