Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-5564808-20131226192356/@comment-24077689-20140113230411

Hitting random is a massive clusterfuck of old and shit stories. Which, granted, a huge majority of stories on this site are subpar at best, but we're talking about the quality of creepypasta as a whole. You can't say that all of creepypasta is stagnant when there's still a good population that are good or often great.

It's like saying all the population of the US is heterosexual because the majority of people are. Hitting random doesn't give you an accurate read because you're more likely to get an old or bad story, shit half the time you won't even see the good stories.