User blog comment:Forestfleet/What Is Everyone's Top Five Favorite Creepypastas?/@comment-4560779-20140110022816

1. NES Godzilla Creepypasta (Red.  Just Red.)

2. Abandoned by Disney

3. Extra Ketchup (it's put me off fast food, at least for a while).

4. NoEnd House

5. The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas.