User blog comment:CoughOfFire/Scary Creepypasta's?/@comment-25052433-20140829010131

Best piece of starting advice that I can give you, don't open a blog calling people's work here trash. Certainly don't blame other people for causing yourself to write trash. That sets a bad tempo from the start, and will play a major role in people ignoring you instead of stepping in to help you out.

With that said, it would seem like you've mostly been reading the big name pastas and not really going deep into the site and finding the amazing gems that are on display.

For starters, since I am far from above self promotion, feel free to click on my user name and check out my work. I am not sure if it will deliver the scares that you are looking for, but I am proud of what I produce and certainly enjoy sharing it with other people.

Other great, mostly undiscovered works around here are,

In the Circle

Piggyback

The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas

Those are a few suggestions of well written, scary pastas, that are a little less known, but no less amazing.

Hope this helps.