Board Thread:Writer's Workshop/@comment-9392342-20160401200759/@comment-24101790-20160612233726

I'm sorry but your logic is extremely flawed. Sonic.EXE, Jane the Killer, Laughing Jack, Eyeless Jack (whose author requested the story to be removed under the mention that they wanted to focus on better stories), and Clockwork all have a fanbase, that does not mean their stories aren't flawed or above analysis. They have their spinoffs and are featured on lists too, does that mean they can't improve in any capacity. Claiming they are is an incredibly weak argument. Writers should focus on improving their skills and telling an involving story rather than building up a fanbase. I hope you one day understand that rather than dismiss any criticism under the terms that 'you like the story'.

Now unless you have actual feedback to give to the author, I suggest you stick to our forum rules about commenting without providing valuable feedback.