User blog comment:CrashingCymbal/Crashing Cymbal's Recommended Reading for December 2013/@comment-24077689-20131217173447/@comment-24077689-20131218153246

I can definitely see why you wouldn't like that story. I personally have an affinity for stories in that realm, my favorite Lovecraft story in Behind the Wall of Sleep, which has similar elements of progression.

Cym apparently already saw it but I just stumbled on this one:

Walking Your Dog it's a twist on the classic Choose Your Own Adventure style story. It's written very well and while not overwhelmingly creepy it's a lot of fun. If I'd found this sooner I would have nominated it for PotM.