User blog:MrDupin/The "Reality" Category is (Probably) Messed Up

Recently it was brought to my attention that the "Reality" category needed some sorting out. After I checked for myself, I found a lot of stories tagged as "Reality" don't deserve the tag. Most of those undeserving stories are stories that are set in the real world, without any fantasy/paranormal happenings. According to the category descriptions (here and here) that's not enough.

I am writing this blog for two reasons:

a) I would like to have the category clarified. What exactly fits in the category?

b) I think we should try and clean out the category a bit.

These are some of the pastas that according to the descriptions don't fit the criteria, but they were originally added to the category nevertheless (I removed them now). These are prime examples of the problem with the category: The Big Head-O The Cellar Door The Choosing Beatus The Bedroom on the Second Floor Creepy House I Found in the Woods Kraashin Under the Floorboards I could go on and on, but I think those examples are more than sufficient to get my point across. So, what's up with the "Reality" category?