Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-27023843-20160713121846/@comment-25024572-20160904181130

Wolfgangalpha wrote: Ok i get that slendy has powers but jeff has probably killed more people than slendy and in most storys jeff serves as slenders proxie jeff does seem to be immortal i found out that if you are a creepypasta you get immortality then again you shouldnt believe everything on the internet. Jeff has an advantage because like you said slendy is older that means jeff has more energy as a teen he is faster and can strike quicker and he knows when slenderman is going to attack thanks to his insticts. In my opinion Jeff wins automatically Alright, a few things. First, as someone who has read waaaaay too many Jeff the Killer stories, I can 100% assure you that he doesn't act as Slender Man's proxy in most of them. And even if he did, then he'd be subservient to Slender Man, making this argument moot.

Second, it's never been stated anywhere that Jeff's immortal. And, as far as I know, being a well known Creepypasta character doesn't make said character immortal. Jeff the Killer is, at best, a really stron teenager. Slender Man, as far as anyone knows, actually is immortal.

Third, just because Slender Man is older than Jeff doesn't mean he's slower. We don't know what exactly Slender Man is, so his species, assuming he even is part of a species, could just have an incredibly long lifespan (well, if they're immortal, then they have an infinitely long lifespan), and as far as we know Slender Man could be young compared to the rest of his species.

Even taking that away, speed doesn't do much against someone who can teleport. And sure, Jeff might have instincts (I personally call it "bad writing that just moves along the plot," but whatever), Slender Man has the ability to cause headaches and such just by being around. It's hard to use said instincts with a headache.

Now, even ignoring "Slender Sickness" and instincts and teleportation, no one knows if Slender Man can even technically be injured. Can knives hurt him? Who knows.

So, no, Jeff the Killer does not win automatically. He loses.