User blog comment:SilentKillerlurks/What good Creepypasta could I read?/@comment-5227030-20140702040832

Let me consult my EVERGROWING LIST OF CREEPYPASTAS THAT I LIKED FOR ONE REASON OR ANOTHER. Hasn't failed me yet.

And the list suggests: The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas, A Warning, and Wedding Band.

Also: Growths and Floaters. (These are MrCreepyPasta's readings. These stories are not on this Wiki.)