User blog comment:Underscorre/Jeff the Killer Rewrite Contest!/@comment-26030957-20150929020041

Even though I don't plan on entering at this point, I have to agree with Shadow on the judges. This contest is obviously a really big deal and there is not even one administrator on the panel (this is in no way a reflection on the judges chosen, particularly Dupin and Grim who always leave very insightful and thorough reviews).

Here is a list of people whose opinions I respect very much, who I consider very well read and intelligent, and who I think should be added to the panel if at all possible: So Pretentious, Umbrello, Jay ten, Underscorre, Koromo, LolSkeletons, Empy, Dorkpool, and Garbage Factory (if you can find him, he seems to have gone AWOL).

Here is how I would have the judging work, a score of one to ten given for each of these merits: concept, structure, dialogue, character, creepiness, and scariness. The judges should concur in private and the average should be given for each story with the particular score given by each judge remaining anonymous.

If you are going to allow a JTK story back on the site and have it narrated by the biggest name in the business who has nearly a million subscribers the judging should be taken very, very seriously.