Board Thread:Writer's Workshop/@comment-25241458-20150301140332/@comment-25941663-20150301151630

A pasta can have anything the writer wishes it to have. I don't believe there are 'bad ideas' and 'good ideas'. In most cases, it is the execution that counts.

To answer your question: Yes, a creepypasta can have a sympathetic and scary killer, but in my opinion, it is very difficult to pull off.