User blog comment:Dorkpool/Are Some Stories Above Crtiticism?/@comment-25987771-20150412155049

There are a number of stories that deserve the reputation they have. I still find suicidemouse.avi to be an above-average Lost Episode, Candle Cove is still creepy as hell, and Ben Drowned is probably the most polished of the Haunted Cartridge pastas.

But, no. No story is above criticism. The very very best stories have flaws, however minute. It's the author's job address them, and not treat their story like the "Citizen Kane" of creepypastas, even if they're highly praised.