Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-9646452-20130517013437/@comment-6195799-20130615164114

Wizardbaker wrote: Oh no, I don't hate the ending because it's happy. I just think it's...I'm sorry...lame.

Ok, I'm being harsh, but really. I just think that "oh, my girlfriend is being tortured by a video game demon that killed her and I need to defeat it in an ultamite final battle with muh bested friend lizards, and my girlfriend is here to help fight the baddy" is...really silly.

It just felt out of place. It tried to tie everything together when really, things could have been much better leaving things a little vague, letting mystery stay.

It didn't need to be a sad or dark ending, a good ending could work. I just think this wasn't the way.

There were fairly obvious hints at Melissa's true fate throughout the story. It wasn't something the author just came up with at the end. Now, was the foreshadowing very good?....eeeeeh no not really. But there are plenty of problems with the story. It's not one of the best written horror stories, it's just one of my personal favorite creepypastas. It's the monster, it's the subject matter, it's the length, it's the well edited pictures, and I do defend the ending. And if they're fighting each other through the video game it would figure that you would use the characters you had been using throughout the entire game.

One thing I also wish is that Cosbydaf never abandoned Godzilla: Replay. Why set up the whole Transcendence Project thing if you have no long-term vision ofi t?