User blog comment:Underscorre/Vote for the Winner of the Jeff the Killer Rewrite Contest!/@comment-27258351-20151128231856/@comment-25980905-20151201012918

2) I'm not very experienced with the spinoff appeal but I do browse its page from time to time and (last time I checked) there is an entry in the site rules about it. What I do know, however, is that the spinoff appeal is a bit tougher than your regular story submission method. Stories submitted to this section would have to be exceptional to be considered as an exception to the blacklist. Mainly because topics under a blacklist have become redundant and (for want of a better phrase) 'over cliched'. As an example, read some Pokemon Creepypasta, the majority of them follow the same tropes and cliches (say g'day to lavender town for me, would you?).

On the topic of Jeff the Killer, however, I must admit that the likelihood of a Jeff the Killer spinoff being allowed on the wiki is a stretch (I can already see you typing about this contest so I'll stop you here and explain). As mentioned above, a Jeff the Killer spinoff being allowed on the wiki is a stretch. There are reasons why the submissions for this rewrite contest were to be posted on pastebin. And there are reasons why only the winning rewrite will be allowed on the site.

To answer your question, you definitely could submit a spinoff for the characters mentioned above. But the likelihood of them passing through the spinoff appeal process is quite low. There's a reason both of the original stories were deleted from the site, and it wasn't just the writing.

This is all based on my own conceptions and experience. None of it should be taken as the complete truth. This is just how I see things.