User blog comment:Ravagerofrepent/What is the creepiest pasta on the wiki?/@comment-25052433-20151015015548

This is a hard one to answer. Clearly, I can't miss the chance to self promote and say that my pastas are the creepiest, but honestly, that's up to the reader, not me.

As for what I've read that I liked a lot here, a couple that come to mind:

Heavenly Star

The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas

Rumpelstiltskin

My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me on Facebook

And one of mine, just for fun,

Secret Bar