Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-4750363-20131023020818/@comment-24077689-20131104073740

Cataclyzmika wrote: I enjoy reviewing the stories here as much as I like reading them, so it's in my interest for a reviewer team to be formed, I may even apply myself. This idea could work if the reviewers that are selected for the job leave comments that are unbiased and honest but also critical and constructive, no flat out troll reviewing where the aforementioned "reviewer" would pretty much say that a story sucks without giving good reason for their labeling it so or those who base their reviews solely on personal opinion.

This seems to be a very sound idea and would work as long as the right kind of reviewers are selected for it. I agree 100% I've been trying to leave good reviews for people with constructive critique but I feel like I'm getting drowned out by the people that are either in class A) saying "this sucked" or class B) saying "OMG 10/10"