User blog comment:A-Lord-Over-Birds/Jeff the Killer - Debunked (and dismissed)/@comment-24944473-20140805165222/@comment-3999760-20140806140611

Jeff the Killer is not really a good horrible story in general. Much of it doesn't make any sense and pretty inconsistent with plot. Most people that like this pasta are usually teenagers (or younger) who wouldn't touch a horror novel. Then create shameless spinoffs and ripoffs that sometimes is worse than the source material.

Now, I have seen somewhat well Jeff the Killer rewrites and spinoffs, but it doesn't excuse that the source material is crap with a obnoxious fandom who refuses to see the flaws in the story.