User blog comment:CreepyDreams/What is you FAVORITE Creepypasta?/@comment-24569600-20140505195416

Lost episode:

Suicide mouse, I like the mystery aspect, like they didn't explain what was realy on the tape, then you could also avoid all the hyper-realism of squidwards suicide.

Killer:

Uhh, I've only read Jeff the Killer, but that was just disgusting, so, none of them.

Internet Based/Game:

It would have been a toss up between Lost Silver and Herobrine, but Herobrine has been ruined by those idiots on youtube and in forums HE'S FAKE! Also, I have no idea what the endermen chunk is about, so, Lost silver.

Mystical Creature (I Guess...)

The Rake or Slenderman, Slendy because of a kind of mystery, and Rake because it's just short and sweet. NOTE: I do not support the theory that the rake is Slendy's dog, that is Stupid.