User blog comment:StevenUniverse45/Favorite Creepypasta?/@comment-26373253-20150613200245

My favorite pasta EVER is Autopilot, closely rivaled by The Pastel Man. Anything on my page I consider a good story, but I have some I've forgotten to add. Black Hole Sun or literally anything by Empy is also a fun read.

As mentioned below, The Showers is a great tale also.

http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:468612

The thread above is also full of good recommendations.