User blog comment:Whitix/Choose Your Own Adventure Style Story/@comment-25941663-20150726125701

That is funny, I was thinking about making a Choose Your Own Adventure pasta too a few months ago. I even messaged Underscorre about it. Regarding the table of contents thing, he told me I could use the magic word to hide the contents. Then, as options you would put links that "jumped" the page to the correct part of the story. Something like this:

http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Creepypasta_Wiki:Spinoffs#Blacklisted

See the #Blacklisted at the end of the link? That tells the browser to jump the page to the specific section. Essentially, there would be no scrolling needed, and it would be easy to set up.

Honestly, if I had more time I would do this myself. But since I don't, I will share some of the ideas I had come up with. Maybe they'll help you, maybe not.

I too was thinking that the nature of the story should be explorative. By that I mean I would 'drop' the reader in a creepy location (eg. a dark forest) and I would let him wonder around, exploring, finding secrets etc..

Another idea I had (although a bit trickier) is a whodunnit type of story. Essentially, a group of people (including the reader) would get trapped in a place (eg. a mine) and the idea is, one of the people is a murderer/monster/whatever and the reader would have to find out who, or something like that.

Finally, I was thinking about a more traditional creepypasta setting. The focus of the pasta would be on plot/story, and less on exploration. Essentially, it would be an interactive story, where the choices of the reader wouldn't matter that much, but it would stir the story in slighly different directions.