Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-24127605-20131103193530/@comment-24077689-20131116023128

XrosHeartless wrote: Noothgrush wrote: Somebody mentioned it.

Silent Hill: Revelations was the biggest crapheap of a disappointment I've ever seen. It's like OK. Silent Hill 2.. what will make money? Sean Bean? Cool. Pyramid Head? Cool. 3D? You bet your ass! Lets also throw in a bunch of the mythology from the games as possible with no context and little relation to the first movie. I was talking about the game, the one everyone liked. I can understand how the movies really get on people's nerves but I honestly felt that the second tried a bit harder, not saying it succeeded, but it tried.

Yeah, the game is a masterpiece.

I loved the first movie, I thought that the storyline was coherent, interesting, the characters were good, you got to know them, they developed well. Even if it did deviate from the game franchise it remains a good movie. The second movie was just awful, the acting was bad, the characters were terrible, and all the wonderful work they did with the monsters in the first film just became CG messes in the second. It was a big disappointment.