Creepypasta Wiki talk:Deleted Page/Jeff the Killer/@comment-24213926-20131204174024/@comment-4970423-20131207183355

I agree that the story was good for what it is, but the reason alot of people think it's bad is because they either

A. Didn't read the real story of Jeff.

B. Read too many spin-offs/'Jeff Formula' stories

If you ignore all the horrible remakes of this story (It's almost like Hollywood remaking a movie from the 1980's that everyone loved. It's godawful and should've been left alone.) and actually look at it in its own right, it's an OK story. I wouldn't give it the rating of 9/10, more like 6.5/10 because alot of the story makes no sense when you think about it.