User blog comment:Blacknumber1/1ST EVER CREEPYPASTA FREESTYLE CHALLENGE - Official Page/@comment-25907694-20150209185600/@comment-26054278-20150209205502

Perhaps it could go:

8/10 or above- Semi-Finalists

Semi-Finals = Judges give the Semi-Finalists the title of the pasta they have to write. Semi-Finalists have 2 days from when they ask for a title, but there is a cut-off date for when the Semi-Finals are over and Semi-Finalists who didn't ask for a title are cut out of the contest.

9/10 or above- Finalists

Finalists = Same as current, except instead of grading on a scale out of 5, grade it on a bigger scale (20, for example).

This essentially is the same as it currently is except it raises the bar a bit and adds another entirely new round. However, I'm not sure if this would be too much work or not.