Board Thread:Writer's Workshop/@comment-25140503-20150608014039/@comment-26007602-20150612090741

I'm going to skip grammar and die straight into the story.

Your theory hinges faaaaar too much on "what if". Reading this:

"But what if the gang hadn't really gone to Atlantis at all? What if instead, the bus was actually a time machine that took the group to a futuristic version of Atlantis?" Where is your evidence for this? There is none presented. You have nothing to support this and since it's the entire basis of your theory, it creates major issues for the rest of the story.

"But maybe it's just a representation of what it could look like in the future." You can't try to prove something by doing this. You need actual evidence to support your theory.

"The futuristic Atlantis in the movie looks nothing like the Atlantis that we last saw, which was in the Season 1 episode Neptune's Spatula." This isn't very convincing as, nobody expects continuity in children's cartoons. You can't expect the creators to do something in season one and then use it again in season seven.

I'm not going to bother explaining any other specific details as nothing here has evidence to support it. Your theory is based upon nothing and isn't really creepy at all. Assuming this were true, how is this supposed to be creepy? The big idea is that Atlantis was invaded and taken over. So...? Am I supposed to be creeped out by the backstory of a children's show? I don't understand the rationale behind the horror aspect of this.