User blog comment:Foxy The Pirate Fox/Worst CreepyPasta Read?/@comment-1186783-20140806171700

I think that, with the exception of Jeff, all the truly horrible ones are deleted. So, I'd probably rephrase the question from "worst" to "most overrated."

IMHO the most overrated pasta I've seen is The House That Death Forgot. It isn't horrible, but I certainly don't think it belongs on the suggested reading list.