User blog comment:Kallier6359/Does anyone know any REALLY scary pastas?/@comment-4849011-20190908123226

Every time I see someone ask this, I'll reply, without question, that the scariest creepypasta I've ever read is "He Was a New Man" by HumboldtLycanthrope. That may not mean much on the surface because I'm the most squeamish person here, but other people have talked about how horrifying and chilling this one is. It gives you no respite from the horror, constantly reminding you that elements of the fictional story were based on real-life events.