Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-34482064-20180312131416/@comment-4849011-20180314234009

For now I'll stick with creepypastas, but I may come back later and talk about other scary stuff. The scariest creepypasta I've read is "He Was a New Man" by HumboldtLycanthrope. There's no escape from the horror because even though it's a fictional story, it was inspired by real-life horrors. For second place I'm tempted to say every Tobit story, though there are a couple more terrifying than the others. Banning does a great job of blending fantasy and horror elements with real-life dangers and emotion, which makes the stories all that more frightening and moving.