User blog comment:CreepyDreams/What is you FAVORITE Creepypasta?/@comment-17758905-20140504192100

Well my absolute favorite not in any of those categories would be A Game of Flashlight Tag, but fine...

Lost Episodes: Easily, my favorite one for this would have to be Squidward's Suicide. It's the only good one I've actually read. There's a plot in the episode that makes sense that's not just blood and guts, and all that stuff. It's actually rather realistic (Hyper-realistic?). It also comes up with decent excuses for most things, and isn't very contrived. The only unrealistic thing, as pointed out by someone else, is that interns usually don't get to watch the episode before it airs.

Killers:

None, they all suck.

Internet Based/Games:

If there's a good one, I haven't read it yet. Perhaps a mod or admin knows a decent one.

Mystical Creatures: Easily the being in Psychosis. It's actually creepy because we have no idea about it, and it's plot, all we know is that only an insane person can actually get away from it, whatever it is.