User blog comment:Hawkbreath/Creepy Stories?/@comment-26054278-20150215022358

Personally, I am in the minority as a person who dislikes 1999, but if you like it, good for you. Personally, I would stick to The Pastel Man, Funnymouth, and The Showers for medium to longer reads, and I'm Worried about My Son as a short story.

I would also recommend Forgotten Valentine for being one of the best stories on the wiki, although not really a Creepypasta.