User blog comment:MrDupin/Why Jeff the Killer isn't a classic/@comment-25024572-20150917125045

No matter what you say or do, there will be people who consider "Jeff the Killer" a classic. I will admit, you make good points, but, in a way, "Jeff the Killer" is a classic. Not in the way that Citizen Kane is a classic; no, it's more like how The Room or Manos: The Hands of Fate is a classic. It's a classic in being awful. Everyone will remember it as an example of how to suck. (Unless you have some weird, fangirlish obsession with the character, in which case you'll probably love him and the story, and write terrible stories that will have to be Riffed once the hiatus is over)

So, it isn't a classic in the good way. But that doesn't mean we should wipe it from the Wiki or try and forget it. No, we should remember it as an example of what not to do when writing.