Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-5269370-20140103013046/@comment-1196539-20140104000857

That would include both of what we're talking about. Anyway, I would personally suggest the iconic creepypastas over the "good" ones because reading what's been popular/had an impact in the past is where new readers develop their understanding of where cliches come from. That would be my suggested reading to users brand new to creepypastas as a whole. Because I would suggest it to them.

Both can be equally considered suggested reading. One for "I'm brand new to creepypastas and need suggestions on where to find out and learn more about them" purposes, one for "I want to read something and this is what community members suggest" purposes.