User blog comment:RuckusQuantum/Scoring System Proposal/@comment-3999760-20150423014649

I don't do a numeric rating system because I think it is counter-productive and doesn't accurately show the quality of the story. Instead, I point out what I liked about the pasta, the plot and flow, and then talk about the faults (every story has faults). I abandoned a numeric system for detail reviews that try to scope the story as a whole.