Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-27023843-20160713121846/@comment-25024572-20160827161256

Creeper50 wrote: Slenderman would win, because he's a much better character, and would not get deleted for quite some time. Jeff the Killer would die because he's not a good character. You get the idea.

Technically, in canon, it was a tie. However, personally, I think Slender Man would win. But him winning because "he's a better character" isn't really relevant here. If the two were to fight, who would win is the question. Being a better character doesn't matter here.

But Slendy would win, and here's why:

Slender Man is, as far as we know, an immortal being who can drive people insane without even touching them. He can make people his proxies, giving him, in a way, an army. In fact, according to some ARGs, he does have an army of sorts. Small one, more like a team, but still. However, even taking away the whole proxy thing, Slender Man physically has multiple limbs, height, and teleportation, giving him an advantage.

Jeff, on the other hand, while hard to kill, can still, in theory, be killed. I'll mainly be using Jeff's original story as canon here, since that's technically the definitive and well known version of the character. While Jeff is insane and has some combat skills, he's only 13 years old and isn't immortal. Furthermore, he doesn't really have any supernatural powers that compare to Slender Man (well, unless you count the power of being OP. I don't).

So, in a fight, Slender Man has multiple advantages to Jeff, including height, powers, limbs, age (he's older, has killed many times before, and knows how to do so), and forces behind him. And, if this is 13 year old Jeff we're talking about, he's pretty much a novice in terms of serial killing, so he wouldn't be adept enough to fend off Slender Man in a physical fight, nor would he be able to outsmart an immortal being with little to no known weaknesses.

Slender Man wins, hands down.