Talk:She-Wolf in Sheep's Clothing/@comment-25947144-20180227224831

Just wrote an entire review and the wiki decided to erase it...thanks a lot, wiki. Sadly I'll have to keep these reviews rather short in wording due to time constraints.

General Quality: I think the best scores should go to a remarkable way of expression, which here is sadly absent in favor of normal speech. Score: 20/25.

Horror factor: Thanks to the song's title and lyrics the tension and mystery were driven rather short, but even ignoring that the plot felt rather artificial due to being rather generic. As a result, the horror factor had to suffer. Score 15/25

Lyric interpretation: As stated by Hel, the take was rather literal, but that wouldn't be a significant issue if the plot didn't seem to lack a deeper meaning as well. Still, I can't complain about how faithfully the lyrics were followed. Score: 20/25

Entertainment value: As mention in horror factor, the artificial feeling of the plot made it difficult to maintain some sort of immersion. As far as horror stories go, not bad, but not remarkable either. Score: 18/25

Final score: 73/100.