Board Thread:Writer's Workshop/@comment-24037587-20140911164319/@comment-25558572-20140911233420

Melodyuchiha1992 wrote: I hear what she says but saying that tossing an idea and moving on really doesn't help. Personally I'm not trying to be mean in my replies but if she thinks tossing a story out is the answer, it's not much help as well as she's seeming more rude than helpful. You see as I put in the first post at this link http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:370442, I want to make my writing a career and I have had a lot of assistance to get it from what it was before which I admit needed a lot of work. I'm not wanting to sound like I'm ranting or butthurt or anything like that, but I read through her comments and after hearing " I think you should forget this idea and move on to a new one..." It seemed more like she was being more rude than anything. I had a couple people read over the comments as well and neither of them thought this was constructive. So I'm sorry if I sound mean but that is not my intentions. If you want to make a career out of writing, you should seriously learn to handle and process criticism instead of trying to defend yourself and invalidate my feedback because of the amount of time you spent on something.

You had a couple others read over this and they agreed with you? Who? Your friends? I don't see any replies here that aren't from me or Zombies. Show me these responses. My later comments may have been less constructive because I was responding to your complaints instead of evaluatiing your work.

If you think I'm being rude, you probably have a very broad definiton of the word. Everything I have said so far regarding your writing has had the intention of helping you improve. I used to make similar mistakes and my earlier work is proof. Honest feedback is not rudeness and if you won't accept this, then I have no more patience with you. You wanted criticism, I gave it.