Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-25760324-20150324171640/@comment-25458443-20161110014407

Any idea can be performed well and this idea has a lot more potential than many others. That being said, the specific pastas you've chosen don't really mesh with fnaf's formula. Maybe Candle Cove but others like NoEnd House and The Sandman are creepier more in concept than in IMAGERY. And Fnaf is all about imagery. If you're dead set on Candle Cove than I would also recommend other stories that have more iconic IMAGERY, things like Slender or something...something more fanart-able than your current choices I guess.

If done right, this could be  simultaneously really creepy and a great testimate to the CreepyPasta community, but if done wrong than it's cringe-worthy at best and forgetable at worst. Don't rush into it because you're excited about a new idea, let it simmer and develop until you have something truley horrific to show to the world.