User blog comment:LadyMasquerade/Help me out/@comment-24821182-20140518152952

I don't understand what you mean by "amateur creepypastas". Are there professional creepypastas? Apart from a ClericOfMadness, I don't even think we have any published authors who write CPs.

I'm guessing you're referring to stories that haven't garnered much attention, and if you're looking for such stories, just click the "Random Pasta"-button. Only a very small percentage of CPs posted on this site end up getting noteworthy attention, the rest descend into obscurity, waiting for someone to stumble upon them by coincidence.