User blog comment:SnakeTongue237/Top 10 Overrated Creepypastas/@comment-28088262-20150406191025/@comment-5643552-20150409050218

I wouldn't even call The Slender Man page a creepypasta, because it's really just a standard wiki article. Like the Wikipedia article for Slender Man only with bullshit instead of facts and no sources cited. Hell, it was even written by multiple users if you check the page history.

"Psychosis" and "Penpal" are both very good, but I think maybe The Sandman would be a better candidate since the "Beings" theme is more pronounced in that story.