User blog comment:Ravagerofrepent/What is the creepiest pasta on the wiki?/@comment-26112985-20151015023216

Well, this is indeed a difficult question, but I will do my best to give you what I hope to be an adeqaute response.

Classic pastas that were scary (Even if some of them are only decent to mediocre as actual stories)...

Abandoned by Disney-- because of the terrifying finale. Also, Slimebeast.

Candle Cove-- Made frightening because of the ambiguity of the ending that lets our minds wander and create our own creepy conclusions.

The Rake-- The entire idea behind this... that a man comes into your room at night and watches you sleep, is extrememly unsettling. I don't care if this one has become less revered than it originally did over time. It is scary.

Underrated Scary Works

Pogo-- This is a recollection of real events that take place in the mind of a real serial killer who murdered over thirty innocent young children. The fact that this really happened alone is unnerving.

Stairs-- Strange murders and an old woman in a wheelchair. I shall say no more.

I'm Worried About My Son-- A micropasta with a chilling twist ending.

Modern Masterpeices

He Was a New Man-- This one is definitely worth looking into, just for how realistic and disturbing it is. Also, a creepypasta has never gone so south so fast.

What Really Watches You in the Dark-- Just what it sounds like.

Ad Naseam, Ad Mortem, Ad Infintium-- The horror of a living hell that cannot be escaped is very powerful.

And (Because BanningK1979 already did this below)...

A small bit of self promotion here. I'd like to think that Crucifix is the scariest pasta I've put out.