Talk:The Midnight Man Challenge/@comment-33470154-20171024175636

This is really one of the best Creepypasta-based-on-other-Creepypasta I’ve read. One question though: According to the beginning, they all went missing, however, the three dead ones were lying in the kitchen and Maddi clearly “won” the game. Was the author implying that the Midnight Man got Maddi after she clearly won the game? I don’t think that’s the way the Midnight Game works. Also, how did the bodies vanish? I am unaware of the Midnight Man stealing his victims after killing them. However, I can overlook these errors because the rest of it is so well written. This is a true masterpiece.