User blog comment:Pacersnation16/What Makes a Pasta Scary?/@comment-24191206-20140414181936

There is alot of things that makes CreepyPasta "creepy".

From the correct use of blood and gore to correctly used build up.

But in my experiences I've found the sense of realism is a helping factor.

The stories I write are based on real events and it makes it impossible for there to be story killing cliches.

Try reading up on some "well-known" CreepyPastas and see how CreepyPasta is done correctly.

I've read and watched so much CreepyPasta I know the in's and out's of how to write it (Even though making an Original one is difficult at times)