User blog comment:Darksparx/Thoughts on What Makes a Good Creepypasta./@comment-24381191-20141109132137

I think what makes a good story is good or enjoyable writing, if it's longer, build up the tension, a good plot and a satisfying end. A satisfying end doesn't mean that you tie up the story neatly in a bow, maybe leave some questions unanswered. You don't necessarily need a twist. Also, if you are unsure of your story being good enough, I recommend using the Writer's Workshop every time. You can get feedback there without risk of it getting deleted before you post it to the main wiki.

There are some stories here that aren't exactly scary, and don't even try to be. I've written one called Earth's Revolt (the link is on my user page if you wanna check it out) and it's gotten mostly positive feedback. Also, no, you didn't break any rules.