User blog comment:MrDupin/Why Jeff the Killer isn't a classic/@comment-26993007-20150919181504

There is one real answer to this question and that is because jeff the killer is a terrible story with terrible writing and several impossiblle features. Anyone with common knowledge and common grammar skills should know that this story is absolutely terrible. Yes it was scary at first and tons of people believed it (the gulible) doesn't change the fact that this story may never be a classic. If one day it does become a classic than this wiki has gone to hell.