Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-5269370-20140103013046/@comment-1196539-20140103223349

But Jeff the Killer and Dead Bart are better examples of what Creepypasta is. It seems you think that being representative of the notion of "creepypasta" directly correlates to a story being good. I think it directly correlates with being popular and well-known; with it having had an impact on the history of Creepypasta, whether that impact was a positive one or a negative one. I'm talking about a history page--you're talking about Creepypasta of the Month with more than one article.

As I said previously, we're talking about two different things. If we want to have a page for what are widely considered good, current creepypastas by the community, fine. If we want to have a page dedicated to creepypastas which have made their mark in history, that's fine too. I'm defining our terms so that we all know what we're talking about, and I think both pages should exist. If we can't agree which one of these two potential pages is suited to being called "suggested reading," then maybe neither should. Maybe one could be called "Historic Pastas" and the other could be called "Community Picks," or something along those lines.