User blog comment:Elaliser/Jeff the Killer is a terrible pasta/@comment-24604889-20140228094846

I agree with almost everything.

Honestly i never thought that Jeff The Killer was a scary story, i always heard all the hype about it, so when i finally got around to reading the pasta, my hopes were fairly high, after the story i thought "really? that was one of the top ten pastas?" what really did it for me was the fact that the kids had guns and threatened anyone not to break up the fight.

So yes the story was a bit childish and over the top, and not very scary, however i won't attack the author because of what they chose to put in their own story, I just don't understand how it got to be so popular.

And while you do bring up some good points attacking the author with such negativity was a bit unnesseccary. Don't antagonize a creator, provide constructive criticism.

All in all i agree with the points you bring up, i don't believe the story deserves all the hype, but be a little nicer with your criticism. :)