Talk:Penpal/@comment-25148755-20150228065133/@comment-26373874-20150506035323

@Zombieassassin175

You bring up one of the major things I have a problem with. We are meant to assume that Josh was dressed in the narrator's clothes that were left behind in his old house, yes? I think we are. But they moved in-between kindergarten and first grade, when the narrator would have been about 5, 6 tops. Josh attended the narrator's 12th birthday party and was abducted soon thereafter, so Josh had to have been at least 12 at the time of his death. He was probably closer to 14 or 15, since Screens takes place when the narrator is 15, and he states, like you said, that the "penpal" had Josh for over two years.

There is absolutely no way a 14 year old can fit into a 6 year old's clothes. No way. I don't care how hard you try, unless Josh was abnormally small, or the narrator was abnormally large as a child, you would not be able to stuff him into those clothes.