User blog comment:SnakeTongue237/Top 10 Overrated Creepypastas/@comment-4715955-20150408100412

I wish your criticisms would go into more detail. A lot of them boil down to "it's predictable, and also not scary" with little substance explaining why. And you don't point out a lot of the glaring problems unique to each pasta. I reviewed Mr Widemouth back when I had a tumblr, and my biggest gripe was "if your monster can be repeatedly defeated by a young child bedridden with the flu, YOUR MONSTER ISN'T SCARY." Mr Widemouth's graveyard must be filled with extremely stupid children.