Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-30161070-20161124023856/@comment-25947144-20161124120345

You don't have an argument, you have opinions. Yes, there's a degree of subjectivity involved in deciding wheter a story is up to the standards, but objectively it's ok. Grammar is fine, a bit of creepiness is there and the story is plausible (even if a bit over the top). And opinions are mixed on it, around half of the comments are positive and another half hates it. Very few are neutral towards it (like me). I truly feel like the fact that it's a Jeff story influences people a lot. If it was an independent story with no correlation whatsoever to JtK