Talk:And the Banshee Cried/@comment-25570744-20141023025912

Okay no, that's such an arbitrary rule. You give no reason she couldn't have offered to make him immortal. No reason he should've known to ask. No reason she couldn't still make him immortal after he told her he had cancer...and you kinda take away the mystical aspect of a banshee when she's just like "oh hi i'm a banshee, let's get married and have 3 kids!"

2/10, Olive Garden quality pasta.