User blog comment:TuggingaRhythm/Can somebody explain to me why Jeff the Killer has the most overprotective fanbase in the history of Creepypasta?/@comment-12521892-20140624205646/@comment-17834624-20140626113906

Jeff's personality was more so "protect brother at all times", so yes he was kind of two dimensional. Randy was more so "hurt everyone, there's no end of days", making him seem even more psychotic than the killer himself.