Talk:Why Sarah Never Sleeps/@comment-25798693-20150225154245

7.5/10

Quite a scary story. Good enough use of mystery, but I have to admit, I still can't understand fully what happened.

Who was Lizzie? Did someone actually walk through the yellow door after Sarah opened it (given that Sarah heard no rustling leaves and that she only saw a solid wall)? Why did Lizzie vanish at some point after the hollow man's arrival? Could she be the hollow man's lackey? I take it the hollow man killed Sarah's parents, why? Wasn't he supposed to only prey on Sarah?

The story also doesn't have a very conclusive ending. I do understand that the mystery about the ending also contributes to the greatness of the story, but what happened in the morning? Does the tomb reference actually mean that Sarah's parents are indeed dead? What happened to Sarah afterwards? And are the tiny claws Lizzie's or the hollow man's, or even somebody else's?