Creepypasta Wiki talk:Deleted Page/Jeff the Killer/@comment-17705753-20130904173124/@comment-5643552-20130904181231

If you would read the earlier comments, you wild see that that is precisely the problem many people have with it: its lack of creepiness. The surrealistic nature of the story destroys many reader's willing suspension of disbelief, thus detracting from the overall experience. Horror is something you must experience – if it fails to engage the reader, it fails to be creepy.