Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-4833240-20140301051701/@comment-5619531-20140304054114

It's all just being constructive. Why, shit. I even view the deletions that the administrators/VCROC do as critique. If it's not one of those damned trollpastas/spam pages, and it gets deleted due to quality reasons. A user can be like "What did I do wrong? Maybe I should ask the admin/VCROC why they deleted my article?" Rather than being one of those users who threaten the administrator.

Shit, we can't give the user who doesn't know a clue about grammar/story telling an ass-pat and a cookie. If it's constructive criticism, even if it's to the point of making yourself look like the criminal, it helps out with the user. Take Papercuts, for example, there were a lot of plot holes in that story. A great example of criticism, from Callie's standpoint if she were reading the story, "This fucking sucks. What did Mickey find at the end of the story that made him die?"

Not targeting Dubious, but this is a great example of criticism. In his story, Humannequin. Sure it's not real, but the most unrealistic thing that I have read in this was that the person was writing what he saw within five minutes. Pancakes in the comments, and I in a pm with Dubious, said that the person writing what he sees is under five minutes is too unrealistic. It would be best for the person writing it to have the thing that the person was writing be written in 10 minutes or more, and not five minutes.

Troll comments, like "LOL, DIS IS STUPID -69/9001" and targeting the author like "The author is a dumbfuck, and should go kill themselves." should just be blacklisted.

Cursing represents feeling, emotion, about what the person thinks of it. If I expressed my feeling with "This fucking rocks! 50/50!" And upload it on my profile page as one of the best fucking pages on this site. Or if I said "This is the most downright piece of shit, ever. 1.9/10" and I have the urge to delete it, but I can't due to its reputation. I even did that in the comments of The Lion King Sega Game Creepypasta. And the author even admitted in the comments that it wasn't his best work on the site.

Any writer, first time or a person who has been writing for 50 years, shouldn't get a pat on the ass, a cookie, and a sticker that says "GOOD JOB! YOU DONE GOOD, EVEN IF IT'S NOT GOOD!"

TL;DR - The writers on the wiki are not a bunch of two year olds sucking their thumbs, and the person who is commenting on it should be nice and gentle to the little baby. We should all accept the criticism like a bunch of teenagers/young adults/adults that we are. Even if it does sound down right mean.