Talk:Penpal/@comment-26566389-20150702183713/@comment-26981243-20150912195413

1) The reason he killed Mrs. Maggie is because he's plan to have her lure them in the house wasn't working and he no longer had a use for her 2) The stalker wanted the narrator to himself so he wanted to kill Boxes in order to force him to cut ties with the things he loved and move the narrator closer to him. 3) However, he probably accidentally killed more cats thinking they were Boxes, which explains the other dead ones. Its dark down there and I doubt he was using a light. 4) What Josh meant is that the narrator changed dramatically and wasn't the same person he was first friends with. The narrator becomes obsessed with finding boxes and the polaroid's and Josh feels like that his friend is no longer there anymore, and is instead a kid obsessed with figuring his stalker out. 5) The stalker was trying to distance the narrator from his mother by explaining that Josh had ran away, and then dragged him into the forest to seem like Josh actually HAD ran away. He was hoping that the betrayal would make his mother love him less in some twisted way.  6) The stalker was so obsessed with the narrator and wanted to be with him forever. He felt that the only way to do that was to die with him so their souls would be together in the afterlife. The reason he chose to just die Josh's hair is because he no longer had a way of contacting the narrator, and clearly the narrator didn't recognize the stalker in the theatre, so he used Josh instead.