Talk:Smile Dog/@comment-26045820-20150205162318

I think this is one of those famous pastas that deserves most of it's praise. And for good reason.

The setup is classic without being cliche. The way that they describe the original  posting of the images through those deceptively innocent e-mails is quite dubious (and slightly disturbing).

The image itself is pretty well inherently creepy and uncanny in many ways. And the fact that the author remains a mystery really does add to that factor of mystery of truth.

8/10