Board Thread:Chat Discussion/@comment-24463401-20140608232520/@comment-4998996-20140610032005

Fatal Disease wrote:

The Damn Batman wrote: Any questions, leave them here in the comments. Also inform all mods who are unaware of this thread. I actually have three questions. The first question is why can't we comment on the blogs? I feel as though that they should be commented, given critique, or supports and opposes as to see if they deserve the privilege to be a moderator or not. It'll actually put use into the blogs that all moderators are actually permitted to do so, rather than wait until 9 days to do so. Or at least include that it's all part of Phase 2 (the voting, I believe), and have the voting once every moderator is doing (I think that's what you plan on doing, since it just says Phase 2, but you included three phases). And remember what you said in the first thread, that everyone, including moderators, can comment on these.

The second question is why are they blogs? I see that there's a project page explaining how to do this. I think that the moderator should write it out in the namespace of the project page (Project: Requests for Chat Moderator/Recount/Fatal Disease), follow the whole process in the rules, and bam. The app's done. It will also prevent blog space, since the apps seem that they wouldn't be commented.

And the third question is why are the moderators that were demoted a month before this whole entire thing was instituted, gets to have a second chance? What I meant by this, I can see the whole "inactivity" reason, since we had lost three moderators due to this. But other moderators, like ChaoZ (sorry for using you as an example, you're the only one that fits this example), that actually went through the whole demotion process, got supports by some, if not a lot, of users that actually agree with the demotion (including some administrators), and the user was demoted on fair grounds, and administrator had included that the user should not have any rights on this wiki again.

Those are my three questions about it. 7 Supports and 1 Oppose. That isn't a lot when you consider the amount of users on this wiki.