User blog comment:MrDupin/Why Jeff the Killer isn't a classic/@comment-25462697-20150920004141

As much as people joined for Jeff the Killer, keep in mind that it was a copypasta.

In reality, they only joined to read it, not more not less. IMO, the story doesn't deserve it's place for being a Classic. It doesn't give a newcomer a good, scary read.

It could be popular, and it could be why people come here, but it doesn't change the fact that the pasta is below average and pretty mediocre.