User blog comment:ThatDamnSpy/Nothing's Creepy Enough/@comment-24685965-20140320170651

I remember a story called "Thumps" being fairly creepy. It is a pretty old story, so the concept may have been done to death by now. All I know is that it is one of my favorites.

Also, you said no famous ones, but I am going to suggest "Psychosis" just in case because that one isn't as well known as the most pandering ones like Jeff.

Shameless self promotion: I uploaded a story called "Seen" but it's long and has a slow buildup to be warned.

If you are looking to get a childlike sense of terror, I am sad to say that you have probably lost too much innocence to enjoy these stories like you once could. It's true that many are just plain lousy, though.