User blog comment:Matthewthebionicle/worst creepypasta/@comment-26245108-20150327220536

I'd say "JEFF the Potato" (and he isn't even a CP anymore)...

The story was way to generic, the plot made no friggin sense, and who the hell makes a potato version of one of the well known CreepyPasta characters of all time?!?!?!

To make a long story short, "JEFF the Potato" just sucked (and I'm surprised that it is no longer a CP story).