User blog comment:ChaoZStrider/1st update/@comment-4295646-20120904025843

Of course you should write a creepypasta; I'd encourage anyone who enjoys reading them to try their hand at crafting one of their own. The subject matter, though, is not something I think should be chosen by someone else. Do you have more material for any of the above categories than another? Is there a particular idea roiling around in your head? Good narrative fiction isn't something that comes prepackaged. Write something you think is pretty interesting and scary and worth reading, and that is fun to write. That's all I can really tell you at the outset!

What you say about being a roleplayer - a very creative roleplayer - gives me the minor worry that you'll consider basing your story on some wildly original RP universe that you and your friends invented. It's happened before. And while this doesn't necessarily make for bad writing, it does kind of leave the average reader in the dust about your setting. That's all; just keep accessibility in mind as well.