User blog comment:GoreDust/Need Help Finding A New Creepypasta!/@comment-24304936-20140225164112

Going against the grain here, but try hitting the Random Pasta link a few times too. I have, in the past, found some great stories that have been overlooked for whatever reason. I think when a story goes for what passes as "viral" on this site, a lot of other (sometimes even superior) stories get overlooked.

Give it a try.