Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-32474708-20180125044614/@comment-25458443-20180126102930

I have many personal problems with the way this site functions, but very few systematic ones. I really don't see your point about the minimums being "too low" and can't even wrap my head around your point here. JtK 2015 is a good example because, although I personally agree that it isn't particularly "scary", any argument that it doesn't deserve a place here is completely and factually false and poorly thought out, because unless we are going to put into place a set of rules that define, like, specific "types" of horror, there are no rules that can keep a story like that off the site. You get me?

Like, any argument you can make about JTK 2015, I've heard it. "It's not scary," "I don't like his annoying parents," "Why didn't he kill his bro?" "This doesn't resemble the original story" those are all stupid but like, valid, i guess. Technically, coherent, at least. And you're allowed to think JTK sucks, and you aren't obligated to be scared by a story conceit that isn't scary to you.

What we aren't allowed to do, cause it would be idiotic otherwise, is define the quality standards by what personally scares us like honestly really think about what you're saying here.