User blog comment:RuckusQuantum/Scoring System Proposal/@comment-5632489-20150421105006/@comment-28938497-20150421110540

Eh, I think you kind of need both. I've seen people who've left REALLY harsh reviews that mention absolutely nothing positive about the story and just spend three paragraphs saying nothing but extremely negative things, and then later tell me they liked the story.

You do need to grade the story too, just to add some clarity.