User blog comment:Widward/put these on the trollpasta wiki/@comment-5000412-20180120233342

I don't see any merit to your argument(s) considering you didn't make one. But nonetheless, I'll make a comment for each.

-Jeff the Killer 2015: It might not be very good, but look what it had to work with. I think the attempt itself is interesting, despite the many hangups (some of which are quite consistent to the original story). It should be looked at for how it is: not good, but at the same time, not a troll-level attempt.

-Happy Appy: The author requested it to be moved, so there's no way it could be moved again to the trollpasta wiki (unless they, for some reason, approved of it). That fact aside, it's really not that bad as far as a "lost episode" style pasta goes. I think it gets way too long and layered for its own good, and it of course hits the usual cliches. But a story having problems and cliches (or even just being bad) shouldn't constitute it as a trollpasta.

-Squidward's Suicide: a more defensible one, but I just get the feeling that it doesn't fit well with the big trollpastas. It would probably just be better to just delete it from the site, rather than put it up with Sonic.exe and JTK. Don't get me wrong, it's a bad story. But its bad in ways that are a little less ludicrous than other terrible counterparts (especially in the lost episode category).

-Psychologist: Really don't get your argument for this one. Yes, it has many problems and inconsistencies (I haven't read the prequel), but it's hardly a troll. Again, a failed attempt doesn't equal a trollpasta. It's easy to see that there's a different level of effort made here.

-Straving Dogs: Again, haven't read it. But considering CS wrote it, it's probably not worth moving.

-Harbinger Experiment: This one is actually quite enjoyable, even though it makes some terrible mistakes near the end (ex. the use of Tiny Tim was ridiculous). It's a bit cliched as a whole, especially since it concludes rather abruptly with the it's-still-out-there idea. I'm actually more disappointed with it because I feel it could've been much better, if the writer took more time to be original and make me care about what was happening. It's true that popularity doesn't equal quality, so I'm not sure if it's worth the title of POTM (but then again, popularity is what makes one), but certainly far from a trollpasta.

-Dolly Molly: Yeah, it's pretty bad. It's ending is a blatant rip-off and it hardly develops any scene or character (even to a minimal extent). It's more on grounds for just being deleted, since it's simply boring. Why does it even deserve to be moved?