Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-4750363-20131023020818/@comment-10950063-20131025194402

I think what it needs to come down to is a history of writing good stories, making good edits and leaving good feedback. For that you just need to look into a person's history. A quiz won't show how useful a person will be. It'll weed out a few people, but I don't think anymore than glancing at someone's record.

Also, I think one of the goals of the review team should be leaving feedback. When someone's story gets deleted, usually they're just confused. When they ask why they get a response that doesn't go into specifics, just possibilities of why it might have been removed. That doesn't help them at all. It's a tedious process, but if you want to raise the quality of the site you need to tell people exactly what they're doing wrong and help them to do it right.