Talk:Penpal/@comment-33783946-20171127015957

I created an account just so I could ask this because I think I missed something in this timeline and it's driving me CRAZY. Help me.

So: After the Narrator's 12th birthday, Josh decided to recreate the Map as a gift. And that's when he went missing, and that's why the map was in his pocket, right? Veronica also said that he went missing when he was 13, so that fits the timeline I guess (assuming he could be a littler older than the Narrator for some reason). But then the Narrator's mom says that both the Stalker and Josh died at the same time, as Josh kiilled the stalker and then couldn't get out of there. So I understood that Josh died when he was 13, right after the last time he had seen the Narrator.

BUT Josh's dad just started getting those Jobs after Veronica died, and Veronica died when the Narrator was 15. And he says the guy payed him to fill the holes just one month before, so, still, after Veronica died. So that means he was payed to burry the Stalker and his son when the Narrator was 15. But then, Josh couldn't have died when he was 13, he had to have died 3 years after that, when the Narrator was 15. Also, the Stalker couldn't have died at that time, because he was the one who killed veronica, right? So Josh has to have died AFTER Veronica. Then, where had he been all along for 3 whole years? And why the fuck was the map still in his pocket after all that time?

WHAT DID I MISS. IM CONFUSED.