Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-32757962-20170803192210/@comment-24101790-20170819142407

Joe Thecreeper wrote: there were plenty of good scary stories that were taken down for the stupidest reasons. it doesn't matter. everyone liked creepypasta because it was a chance for them to share their own stories freely, now it's just like a stupid episode of america's next top model, with a bunch of stories being judged by bozos.

That's a pretty flawed approach, just look at sites like Frightening Pasta Wiki that tried the no QS mindset. Tell me how active that site is nowadays and the people's activity on those wikias (commenting on stories, editing, etc.). Having no requirements tends to result in lazy writing that very few people will bother to read.