Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-4833240-20140301051701/@comment-4832646-20140303181312

Are you trying to imply that Guy and I have no idea what we're talking about? What I gave right there was actually a critique. I may have swore, but not only did I point out what was wrong, I listed how to fix it.

As I've pointed out, and Guy has pointed out, as long as a review isn't "-10090399404843487923742873409287/10 THIS SUCKED BALLS GO KILL YOURSELF!", but points at the problem and lists how to fix it, it can be a constructive criticism.

On top of that, that particualar criticism, when used, would be used when a person put either 1. Literally NO effort into the work at all, whatsoever or 2. So little effort that the criticism is well deserved. Oftentimes, it's not.

It's not that hard to write. All this site requires is that you know the basics of storytelling and how to spell and use correct grammar. When you put up a story in the public eye, expect it to ripped apart if you've not put the effort required into it. For heaven's sake, you're acting as though we SHOULD moddy-coddle every new author who comes here.