User blog comment:Dr Bunnyman/What Was Your First?/@comment-4643170-20140428160116

The first pasta "creature" I heard of was Jeff the Killer. I honestly just found myself rolling my eyes and shaking my head at the story when I actually found it. It was only the second largest disappointment in my life.

The first pasta I ever read was something a friend sent me. Pokemon Black. It was never scary, but it was enough to catch my interest and make me look for more creepypasta.