User blog comment:Imjustthere/I've got a question/@comment-36627132-20190728050607

Cupcakes: Even at the time this was written it wasn't any good. I'm pretty sure the only people who enjoy it are hardcore bronies who call for there to be a popular MLP Creepypasta.

Jeff the Killer: I understand how children and teenagers might think the character is awsome, especially those who have been bullied and see him as everything they want to be, but I don't see how anyone over 18 years old could find the story appealing.

Sonic.exe: Like JTK, I can see this appealing to the younger generation, but not to adults. It could have been a decent story if it were written better, had less cliches, and didn't have that stupid ending with a Sonic plushie popping out of the computer screen. Even worse is that there are people who are trying to claim that it set up a lot of the cliches that it plays on, when in fact it used a lot of tropes that were already dried up even for the time.

Spin-Offs: Some spin-off stories are great (most of the Slender Man stories on here, Memoirs of a Set Designer: A Candle Cove Story, Candle Cove Experiences: Tales of the Laughingstock, one of the BOB stories, etc.), but some are just awful. In particular any spin off of Jeff the Killer or Sonic.exe. I don't understand how people look at these crappy stories about crappy stories enjoyable.

As for Squidward's Suicide, you had to have been around during Creepypasta's early years to appreciate it. To people who are new to CP it might not seem like much, but to those of us who were around when it was written look at with nostalgia and still regard it as a great story.