Talk:Eyeless Jack/@comment-25083849-20140622201252

How is this a classic again? The character of Eyeless Jack is interesting and the writing isn't too bad, but it's not a "classic". It's like Jeff all over again; EJ's popular because of the picture, not the story. Come to think of it, most of the well known Creepypastas are popular because of what they look like, not what they do. Hundreds of pictures of EJ portray him as a "HAWT SEXAH GAWD" more than a scary cannibaltisc serial killer. The story itself is decent, but it's nothing to praise about.