I want to start of by saying i'm not trying to defend the pasta or JC the Hyena in any shape or form. And also, THIS IS MY OPINION.
Sonic.exe, one of the worst creepypastas and one of the most cliche pastas. Some even consider this as the worst creepypasta but is it. Don't get me wrong, it is poorly written and overrated but it is it the worst.
NO! Sure the pasta has many problems (like the pasta having many cliches (e.g hyper-realism) and a crappy plot) but there are worse creepypastas like Jeff the killer. Sure Sonic.exe is about this game disc that has sonic writen on it and it has a demonic sonic game inside with many cliches and 4th wall brakes with Sonic killing his friends and Robotnik and anyone who dares play the game will be hunted down by a sonic plushie (probably) from hell but Jeff the killer is about this guy called Jeff who goes crazy after a fire caused by bullies and then his face goes messed up but he fixes the problem by cutting a joker like smile so he is always smiling and cuts of his eyelids so he always stays awake and then kills his family for no good reason and then runs away to kill more people.
Be honest, which story would you rather read? yeah I thought so.
So, what is the answer to the question on the title? the answer is NO, Sonic.exe is a poorly written and terrible pasta but there are far worse pastas out there on the web
thank you for taking your time to read this (if you did read this) and i will like to hear your thoughts and opinions of the pasta.