The classic ones. they have charm
Either Hypno's Lullaby or Slenderman
The classic ones, you can create your own character design for most of them. (example: jane everlasting, eyeless jack, etc.)
Slenderman and Jeff the Killer
I like Laughing Jack a lot.
As Long As I Like Mickey Mouse, Suicide Mouse.
BEN drowned. Always
Toby and lj
@Bendrowned12123 no its ben drowned-
Sometimes it's BEN, sometimes it's Ben, sometimes it's ben.
There's no correct way.
Now please do not take this any further. Don't even reply unless you're going to list your favorite creepypastas, just for the sake of being polite.
What do you think?