A lot of the A-tier stories could stand to be lowered a few tiers. I mean, is Robert the Doll really a better creepypasta than Burgrr Entries? Does The Backrooms really belong in B-tier?
Also, I think you should remake this and just have the image be the name of the story. Based off imagery alone, I don’t recognise about 1/3rd of these pastas. What is that corrupted Kermit in the top left?