I’m pretty sure my first one was “Abandoned by Disney”

A classic

Yeah, I remember being very sp00ked by that one, back when I didn’t really know what a creeper-pasta was

Me neither. I thought it was some "criminal shit", until I decided to explore the subject back in 2021, during the Christmas holidays. Then I became interested of this ever since

Candle Cove, specifically the Something Scary reading of it