Not to mention the most infamous one, the one where the Soviet Russians find God in the woods. We don't even know what it's called.

Neat.

The Soviet Russia God story has been found. It's here.

Also, I feel as if it's worth pointing out that the majority of creepypastas that can be considered "lost" are just bad stories that weren't worth keeping, or stories that were removed at the request of their author. There are probably a handful of worthwhile pastas out there that slipped through the fingers of the internet, but there's nothing we can really do about that.

I know that the soviet one got found, but I couldn't give it a title, per se.

You do make a good point. If anything, the main reason why I was searching for lost pastas was because of potential deleted pastas that could be put on the trollpasta wiki. There could be some secret good pastas though. Also, for ones that the author requested the deletion of, those don't count, unless if the CPW was its only posting. You make a good point BTW.

There are probably a good handful of decent creepypastas (and some media) that were posted on the wiki that got deleted or "lost" for numerous of reasons (copyright, ToS crackdowns, author requests. etc). While I was around in the early era of wiki moderating content, I did not really do a good job archiving since the vast majority of the content being uploaded to the wiki was pretty crap.

While I am interested in "lost" creepypasta since I probably might have some insight, I do not remember anything notable or salvageable from the article listing era.

@Sloshedtrain what was the worst pasta that you remember reading? (When it was still on the CPW)

@Amacooliodude There were some real stinkers I've read. The ones I tend to remember were very NSFW ones due to how brazen, gross they were. One I remember was called "Splitters" that was some edgelord murder gore incest story. Another one was a whole NSFW novel that I didn't notice until the Wikia staff themselves deleted it.