That would be a pretty tall order. I think it's possible, but it would most likely require heavy modifications to the story to pass QS.
@Amacooliodude There were some real stinkers I've read. The ones I tend to remember were very NSFW ones due to how brazen, gross they were. One I remember was called "Splitters" that was some edgelord murder gore incest story. Another one was a whole NSFW novel that I didn't notice until the Wikia staff themselves deleted it.
There are probably a good handful of decent creepypastas (and some media) that were posted on the wiki that got deleted or "lost" for numerous of reasons (copyright, ToS crackdowns, author requests. etc). While I was around in the early era of wiki moderating content, I did not really do a good job archiving since the vast majority of the content being uploaded to the wiki was pretty crap.
While I am interested in "lost" creepypasta since I probably might have some insight, I do not remember anything notable or salvageable from the article listing era.