The first one I remember reading was Orwin, if that is what you mean to ask.
I have never been able to sit through a person slowly repeating the words of a story aloud, so I've never heard one.
I can't remember exactly, but I think it was either Slenderman, Ben drowned, or one of the poképastas
I read the first creepypasta about a year before I joined this wiki. Someone posted a link for Pokemon Black and Super Mario 64 on a forum I used to go to.
Not like that. I was simply too nervous to stand. I was drained and had to be focused on something. I have no idea why or how.
If you see CreepyPasta as something that transcends the site into general urban legends then the first one I had ever known about was Slenderman.
Kids at my school talked about Slenderman a lot, and why wouldn't they? I lived in Bellevue Washington, a city that has full size evergreen trees launching out of people's front lawns. Thick forests were just a regular accepted part of the environment, the trail I walked home through was an elaborate trail through "Ardmore Park" so to hear about a tall faceless and motivationless entity who stalked the woods and killed kids wondering through them?....with photographic evidence and newspapers to boot? That sort of resonated just the right way with a lot of kids I knew...we knew it was a story, but then again...what if it wasn't?
The first story I actually ever offically read on CreepyPasta.wikia was "Why Sarah Never Sleeps" which I stand by being a masterpeice in it's own right. Just not as iconic or evocative as Slendy.
The first CreepyPasta I heard of was the slenderman. I first heard about it when I saw pewdiepie play it years ago. Not knowing what a creepypasta was at the time. I decided to do some research on the slenderman and it led me to more youtube videos about this creature. And then it all started spiraling down when I found tatstops video about the scariest creepypastas. ever since then I loved reading creepypastas.
Sadly Sonic.exe was another early one as well, as well as a few Pokepastas and those idiotic kids show theories that make children's shows unnesecarily dark.