The first draft of Icydice's The Downside of Masturbation made me cry from laughing so hard. You'll have to go looking for it somewhere online.
I'm So Proud of my Daughter, since I am not obligated to post certain deleted pastas.
TEH DAY OF ALL TEH BLOD is a classic, as is WHO WAS PHONE? Both worth reading if you haven't already.
If you go on my profile, in the 'Favourite Wikis' section, you should be able to find a link to 'The Christmas Of Terror Creppypasta Wiki' which is an entire wiki created by Hersis358 dedicated to cataloguing the 6 characters of their one and only creepypasta: 'The Christmas Of Terror'. And when I say 'cataloguing', I mean that the wiki has 6 pages, all of which are akin to '[insert name] is a character in The Christmas Of Terror Creppypasta, here is a picture of them during the events of the pasta', and that's it.
I've no idea why it's in my 'Favourite Wikis' selection, considering I have made literally 1 edit to it and nothing else. Sadly, the actual creepypasta itself isn't on that wiki, but when it was up on this wiki, before it inevitably got deleted, I saw someone comment asking permission if they could post it on the trollpasta/crappypasta wiki (I don't remember exactly which one), to which the author said yes to. So, if you want to read it, I would advise starting there.