I
- I Am
- I Am a Stitched Horse
- I Am at Peace
- I Am Being Followed
- I Am Charlie
- I Am Fire
- I Am Human
- I Am Human...
- I Am Insane
- I Am Nightmare
- I Am Not a Clone
- I Am Nothing
- I Am Never
- I Am Not Afraid!
- I Am Paranoia
- I Am Sam
- I Am Sorry Paul!
- I Am the Abyss
- I Am the Darkness
- I Am the Spider
- I Am Unstoppable
- I Am You
- I Am Yours
- I Am a Zombie
- I Became the Enemy
- I Believe Everything Is Believable
- I Belong Here
- I Can Fix This
- I Can See It
- I Can See You
- I Can't Do It
- I Can't Stop
- I Can't Wake Up
- I Cannot Decide
- I Could Be Anywhere
- I Counted On You
- I Dare You
- I Deserved This
- I Did It
- I Died
- I Didn't Make A Phone Call
- I Didn't Mean It
- I Don't Belong Here
- I Don't Hate Them
- I Don't Know
- I Don't Know if I'm Going to Make It Alive Tomorrow
- I Don't Know What to Say.... *E-mail*
- I Don't Know Where I Am
- I Don't Like the Rain Anymore
- I Don't See Him Anymore
- I Don't Sleep Anymore
- I Don't Think the Employee Handbook Covers Insanity
- I Don't Think This Is Minecraft Anymore...
- I Doubt You Want to Hear
- I Found a Digital Camera in the Woods
- I Found Charlie
- I Found You
- I Go Back to Sleep
- I Got Your Back
- I Hate M. Rossi
- I Hate Meat
- I HATE YOU
- I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream
- I Have You Back
- I Help
- I Honestly Wish I Knew
- I Hope You Win
- I Just Bought It
- I Just Wanna Be Your Friend
- I Killed the Prom Queen
- I Know
- I Know a Secret
- I Know It Wants Me
- I Know Insanity Personally
- I Learned It by Watching You
- I Let Her Out
- I Like Cats
- I Live
- I Lived
- I Lost Her
- I Love
- I Love My Grandma
- I Love My Job
- I Love You
- I Love You Till the Day You Die
- I Love You to Death
- I Love You.... Forever
- I Loved You
- Imagine
- I Met God Today
- I Missed You
- I Need A Cigarette
- I Need Help (True Events)
- I Need to Catch the Train
- I Need Your Eyes
- I Need Your Help Please!
- I Never Liked the Dark
- In Someone Else's Shoes
- I Remember
- I Run
- I Saw Him
- I Saw It!
- I Saw It Coming
- I Scream for Ice Cream
- I See Him Writing
- I See You
- I See You...
- I See You Sleeping
- I See You, Darling...
- I Spy
- I Still Think...
- I Should Have Known Better
- I Should Have Looked First
- I Thought You Liked the Dark...
- I Told You So
- I Used to Be Alone
- I Used to be Fearless
- I Wanna Be The Death
- I Wanna Be the Green Guy
- I Was Adored Once Too
- I Was Never Happy
- I Weep
- I Went to See My Doctor
- I Win
- I Will Always Be with You
- I WILL GET THEM
- I Will Never
- I Will Never Know
- I Wish I Hadn't Ever Done What I Did
- I Wish I Never Did This
- I Would Like to Play a Game
- I, and Only I
- I-Doser
- I'll Always Be Here, I Promise
- I'll Be Watching
- I'll Be Watching Over You
- I'll Find You
- I'll Miss You
- I'll Never Close My Eyes Again
- I'll See You in Hell
- I'm a Demon Within
- I'm a Warrior: Part One of the Slut Strangler Series
- I'm Alive!
- I'm ALiVE.txt
- I'm Alone
- I'm Blue
- I'M DONE
- I'm Everywhere
- I'm Happy, Thank You
- I'm Happy, Thank You Part 2
- I'm Here to Deliver a Warning
- I'm Hungry
- I'm Lost
- I'm No Human
- I'm Not Alone
- I'm Not Done
- I'm Not Insane
- I'm Not Mad
- I'm Not Martin!
- I'm Not Well
- I'm OK
- I'm Outside
- I'm Really Trying
- I'm really a nice person
- I'm So Sorry
- I'm So Sorry...
- I'm Sorry
- I'm Sorry, Daddy
- I'm Still Here
- I'm Sure the Wake Will Be Nice
- I'm Thinking of a Number
- I'm Unstoppable
- I'm Very Hungry
- I'm Waiting
- I'M WATCHING
- Имран Захаев (Imran Zakhaev)
- I'm You
- I’m Your Problem Now
- I've Always Seen Things
- I've Been Watching
- I've Had Another Dream
- I've Been to Hell
- I've Always Seen Things
- IAMD3AD.exe
- Ibid
- Iblis
- ICarly Lost Episode: "Last Show" (Spanish)
- Ice
- Ice Age: Bootleg Tape
- Ice Blue Sin
- Ice Cloud, The
- Ice Cream
- Ice Cream Man, The
- Ice Cream Truck
- Ice Cubes, The
- Ice Man, The
- Ice: The Snowman Maker
- Ichor
- Icy Mountain
- ID 08433906
- IDead
- Ideal Dolls: The Beginning
- Identity of God, The
- Idol, The
- Iexplorer11.exe
- If Only He Could Hear Me
- If They Don't Exist...
- If You Lost a Loved One
- Ikari Kyougi
- Iknieborok
- IKnow.avi
- Illness
- Illness of Agony
- Illusionist, The
- Ilusion.wmv
- Image in the Light, An
- Image in the Mirror, The
- Imaginarium
- Imaginary Friend
- Imaginary Friends
- Imaginary Friend/PT
- Imagination
- Imagine a Spider
- IMDEAD.exe
- Imitation
- Imitator
- Immaculate
- Immersion
- Immortality
- Immortality: The Ingenious Experiment of Director 24-T
- Immortal, The
- Immortal Revenge
- Imp Encounter
- Imp of the Perverse, The
- Impacto
- Imperfect Transition
- Imperial House, The
- Important News
- Imprisoned
- Impossible Proportions
- Impossible Tone
- Impossible Object, The
- Impossible Room, The
- Imscared . exe
- Imscared - Aren't You?
- Imsorry
- In a Flash
- In All of Us
- In Between
- In Between the Static
- In Dreams
- In from the Cold
- In Hot Water
- In My Sleep
- In Salem, Oregon
- In Someone Elese's Shoes
- In the Air Tonight
- In the Attic
- In the Background
- In the Basement
- In the Bayou
- In the Caves
- In the Closet
- In the Closets
- In the Corner of Your Eye
- In the Dark
- In the Dark: A Poem
- In the Darkness
- In the Drawer
- In the End
- In the End...
- In the Hole
- In the Land of the House of Night
- In the Long Run
- In the Mansion
- In the Mind
- In the Mirror
- In the Name of Terror
- In the Office of Doctor Cockroach
- In the Penal Colony
- In the Pines
- In the Pipes
- In the Right Mind...
- In the Shadows
- In the Shower
- In the Summer
- In the Vault
- In the Wall
- In the Walls
- In the Water
- In the Woods
- In the Woods behind My House
- In Which MrCreepyPasta Reads This Pasta
- In Your Dreams
- In Your Mirror...
- Incense
- INOUSAM
- Incident, The
- Incident..., The
- Incinerate
- Inconspicuous
- Incurable
- Index, The
- Indian Rock
- Indian Skinwalker
- Indigo Prophecy: Director's Cut Edition
- Indigo Road
- Indirect Approach
- Indistinguishable
- Indoctrination of Roses
- Indoor Hunting
- Industry Giant: The Dark Side
- Inest Clentia Forti
- Inevitable, The
- Inevitable Ticking
- Infamous - My Sweet Cathy
- Infected
- Infection
- Infection (Number Munchers Creepypasta)
- Infection, the
- Inferior
- Infernal Kiss
- Infernal Ticking
- Inferno
- Infinite
- Infinite Journey
- Infinite Regress
- Infinite Run
- Infinite Insanity
- Infinity Effect
- Influenza
- Inhabitant of Carcosa, An
- Initiation
- Ink.
- Ink Man, The
- Inky
- Inlé Rah
- Inner Beast
- Inner Demons
- "Inner Flame" Pac-Man 2
- Innermost House, The
- Innocence
- Innocent Blue
- Innocence Lost
- Insane Apocalypse, The
- Insane Asylum
- Insane Asylum, The
- Insane Kane
- Insane Man, The
- Insane Sonic - Haunted Mega Drive Cartridge
- Insanity
- Insanity Always Comes Back
- Insanity and Suffering
- Insanity Cavern
- Insanity Driven
- Insanity Has Taken Place
- Insanity in Us
- Intensity of Realities, The
- Insanity of the Beast
- Insanity Stalker
- Insanity's Grasp/The Journal of Christopher Autry
- Insanity's Shadow
- Insect, The
- Insects
- Inside A Game
- Inside Emma
- Inside My Head
- Inside the Cartridge
- Inside the Crawlspace
- Inside Us
- Insites, The
- Insomnia
- Insomnia, The
- Insomnia Ramble
- Insomnia...
- Insomniac
- Insomniac Dreams
- Inspector Gadget
- Inspiration
- Inspiration of the Art
- Inspired
- Instant Death Disease
- Instinct
- Insurance
- Intangible Fears
- Intensity of Realities, The
- Interdiction
- Internet can Kill, The
- Interesting Epitaph, An
- Interference
- Intern, The
- Internet, The
- Internet 2, The
- Internet Crush
- Internet Gateway to Hell, The
- Internet Story, The
- Internet Strangers
- Interview
- Interview with a Nullo
- Interview with the Slenderman
- Into Dust
- Into the Detps
- Into the Forest
- Intoxicated
- Intruder
- Intruder, The
- Invader Zim Lost Episode: GIR's Rage
- Invader Zim: Final Doom
- Invader Zim: GIR Goes Crazy and Stuff (Alternate Ending)
- Invalid User~ Mirror
- Invasive Species
- Inventions From the World
- Inventor, The
- Inventor's Revenge
- Investigation One
- Invisible
- Invisible Friend
- InvisiLynn
- Invitaion, The
- Involuntary Astral Projections
- Investigation, The
- InvisiLynn
- IPad 2
- iPhone, The
- IPod 4
- Iris
- Irisu Syndrome
- Irish Ballad, The
- IRONGIANT . exe
- Iron Gates
- Irony
- Irony is a Painful Bliss
- Irrational Fears
- Irregular Routine
- Is It a Dream?
- Is It Real
- Is It Real?
- Is It Safe Yet?
- Is This Real
- is3dpl3ase.exe
- Isabel
- ISacrifice
- ISAIDNO.MOV
- I See
- ISeeYou
- Island of the Fay, The
- Isolation
- Isolation Lab
- Isolated
- Israfel
- It's Not the Wind...
- Italy Secrets-Lodby
- It
- It All Comes Together
- It Burns
- It Burns...
- It Came From Blood Point Road
- It Came from Behind
- It Came from the Stars
- It Comes at Midnight
- It Couldn't Have Happened
- It Felt So Real
- It Followed Me Home
- It Found Me Again
- It Happened
- It Happened Again Today
- It Has a Rather Lovely Ending
- IT in the Darkness
- It Is Coming
- It Is There?
- It Just Sat There
- It Just Stood There
- It Lives in the Woods
- It Lurks Behind the Mirror
- It Makes No Sense At All
- It Never Ends
- It Never Sleeps
- It Never Stops
- It Runs in the Family
- It Scares Everyone...
- It Shouldn't Have Happened
- It Speaks to Me
- It Started with a Question
- It Was All Yellow
- It Was Better When You Didn't Know
- It Was Cold
- It Was Just a Shadow
- It Was Never Easy
- It Was Never Easy...
- It Was Never There
- It Was There, Sitting and Watching Me
- It Was Written in Blood
- It Wasn't Lavender Town
- It Wasn't Me
- It Wasn't Me... I Thought
- It Wasn't Watching Me For The Same Reason I Was Watching It
- It Watches You
- It Walked with Me
- It Will Be So Much Worse
- It Lives in the Woods
- It Will Never End
- It Worked!
- It/Its
- It'll Be Okay
- It's a Good Life
- It's a Man Eater
- It's a Small World Nightmare
- It's a Woeful World
- It's Always behind Me
- It's Always There
- It's Always Watching
- It's Always Watching Me
- It's Been a Long Time
- It's Better Here
- It's Called Creepypasta for a Reason
- It's Coming
- It's Getting Dark
- It's Golden
- It's HIM
- It's in Their Eyes...
- It's Just a Game
- It's Just an Ornament
- It's Just a Rumor... Right?
- It's Just a Story
- It's Just There
- It's Just the Thunder
- It's Locked...
- It's Masterpiece
- It's No Secret
- It's Not a Myth
- It's Not Real
- It's Not Yours
- It's OK, Your Soul Doesn't Matter
- It's Okay
- It's Only a Nightmare
- It's Only Fair
- It's Only Reality
- It's Routine
- It's So Similar
- It's There Again
- It's Time
- It's Watching Me
- It's In the House
- Its Red Grin
- Itch, The
- Itch in Your Throat, An
- Itching
- Itchy
- Itsy Bitsy
- Itsy Bitsy Spider
- ITWASYOU
- Ivory
- Ivory Extended
- Ivory Spires
- I Went To See My Doctor
- I Won't Leave You
- Izzy's Ghost Story
- Inky