The Judge's Pick: ArinieKat as Drowned Victim of the 1864 Sheffield Flood.
People's Choice: Dr. Frank N. Furter as Dr. Pen E. Flirter.
Runner up: Derpyspaghetti as Pumpkin Love Child.
Runner up: EmpyrealInvective as A Clockwork Orange Droog.
Runner up: Raidra as Michael Jackson.
Runner up: Ricki the vampire as Little Red Riding Hood.
List of Judges for the 2016 Creepypasta Wiki Costume Contest
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.