What's your favorite underrated creepypasta?

Zalgo is actually quite underrated. Infact, unless it's directly connected to the slenderverse, it's generally forgoten. Jeff is really the only exception.

I wouldn't say that Where Bad Kids Go is underrated. Many of the lists of best creepypastas have that story on it, or at least they used to. I really like Happy Sun Daycare, and The Gym Teacher. I don't think those two get enough attention. There was also another one, about a house that becomes like a hell house. It is about renting a cabin. Just can't remember the name of the story.

You're probably thinking of The Comfy and Cozy Cabin. That's one of my favorites.

On the Bus is also underrated in my opinion.

Yeah, that's it. It's been a while since I've read it, but it was one that stuck with me since I first came here.

Yeah, it's a great read. Believe I first read it around 2010 or 2011 on the Creepypasta Index.

Forgot to mention The Stairs and the Doorway and pretty much every other story by Eric Dodd. They're fantastic, and they hardly get any attention.

No, not really. It isn't mentioned very much, but it is pretty well known.

I guess I just don't hear about him much, which is a shame. I thought of another underrated pasta. Anyone ever hear about Good Doctor Locklear?

I like anything HumboltLycanthrope. Someone already mentioned the Gym Teacher, but I liked The Long List the best. Also Borrasca by C. k. Walker.