Zalgo is actually quite underrated. Infact, unless it's directly connected to the slenderverse, it's generally forgoten. Jeff is really the only exception.
I wouldn't say that Where Bad Kids Go is underrated. Many of the lists of best creepypastas have that story on it, or at least they used to. I really like Happy Sun Daycare, and The Gym Teacher. I don't think those two get enough attention. There was also another one, about a house that becomes like a hell house. It is about renting a cabin. Just can't remember the name of the story.
JohnathanNash wrote:
There was also another one, about a house that becomes like a hell house. It is about renting a cabin. Just can't remember the name of the story.